Brooklyn City Pizzeria & Market

Brooklyn City Pizzeria & Market is a standout pizza restaurant nestled in Laguna Niguel, CA, offering a savory slice of authentic New York-style pizza along with hearty Italian favorites. Located conveniently at 30012 Crown Valley Pkwy suite l, this welcoming pizzeria invites guests into a warm, family-friendly atmosphere where the aromas of fresh-baked dough, melted mozzarella, and rich tomato sauce instantly awaken your senses.

The menu here is a delightful celebration of classic and creative Italian-American dishes. Whether you're craving the iconic Pepperoni Sausage and Onion Pizza with its perfect balance of spice and savoriness, or a simple yet satisfying Cheese Pizza Slice, each bite delivers freshness and depth of flavor. For those who appreciate a little indulgence, the Vodka Pizza offers a creamy, tangy twist on tradition, while the Margherita Pizza speaks to simplicity done right with ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, and melt-in-your-mouth cheese.

Beyond pizza, Brooklyn City Pizzeria shines with a diverse array of Italian-American specialties. The Calzone with Sausage promises a golden, crispy exterior encasing rich meats and cheeses, while the Chicken Parm plates arrive paired with perfectly al dente spaghetti, topped with bubbling mozzarella and house sauce. Their Spaghetti and Meatballs is another crowd-pleaser, boasting thick noodles enveloped in a house-made hearty tomato sauce—comfort food elevated. If you prefer something crispy and savory on the side, the Chicken Wings and Baked Wings offer just the right kick, especially paired with their signature Firelli hot sauces, available in both extra hot and hot varieties for true spice enthusiasts.

The beverage selection complements the food beautifully, featuring nostalgic glass-bottled sodas like Mexican Coke made with pure cane sugar, Pellegrino, and American classics like Dr. Pepper. These beverages add a touch of old-school charm to your meal, perfectly matching the pizzeria’s inviting, family-run ethos.

Customers consistently praise Brooklyn City Pizzeria & Market for its exceptional quality and warm hospitality. Antonio Caballero notes, "The pizzas here are delicious. They don't miss if you are near the San Clemente Outlets," capturing the reliable excellence of their pies. Cynthia Ramirez highlights the attentive, friendly service and the consistently delicious food, making every visit an inviting and satisfying experience. Karen Diaz’s birthday pizza feast—half Speziata, half meatball—underscores how their pies inspire outright enjoyment, perfect for special occasions and casual cravings alike.

Paul Kadletz’s endorsement crowns Brooklyn City Pizzeria as the "best pizza in the area hands down," particularly praising the Sicilian slices and customizable Brooklyn-style pies, alongside decadent desserts like cheesecake and coffee cake that are “to die for.” Sarat Varghese appreciates the fresh ingredients and the nostalgic, family-run feel, especially the crisp pepperoni and fresh sauce, even suggesting a small tweak to the crust’s texture to elevate the slice further.

Brooklyn City Pizzeria & Market is more than just a pizza joint—it’s a community hub where traditional Italian-American flavors are crafted with care, where every bite tells a story of quality ingredients and heartfelt cooking. Whether you’re stopping by after shopping nearby or making a dedicated trip, this pizzeria rewards with hearty, flavorful dishes and a cozy atmosphere that feels like a home away from home.